Skip to content

The Leftover Festive Toastie

Leftover turkey and cheese toastie on sourdough with sweet tomato relish

Everything left from yesterday, melted between two slices of sourdough.

By the 27th everyone wants something hot and comforting, and a toastie is the perfect home for whatever's left in the fridge.

Makes 2 · Prep 5 mins · Cook 6 mins · Leftovers

Ingredients

  • 4 slices sourdough
  • leftover turkey or ham
  • 1 handful grated cheddar or sliced brie
  • 2 tbsp Wonky Sweet Tomato Relish
  • butter

Method

  1. Butter the outside of each slice.
  2. Fill with meat, cheese and a good spoonful of relish.
  3. Cook in a dry pan for 3 minutes each side, pressing down with a second pan.

Charlie's cheat

The second pan on top gives you a proper toastie press without the machine.

Make it special

Add a layer of leftover stuffing and a few sliced pigs in blankets before closing the toastie.

Why it works

Buttering the outside of the bread gives an even, golden crust, and pressing it with a second pan melts the cheese all the way through.

Your questions answered

How do you make a toastie without a toastie maker?

Cook it in a dry frying pan and press it down with a second heavy pan. Three minutes each side.

What cheese is best for a toastie?

A mature cheddar for flavour, or brie for melt. A mix of both is even better.

Made with Sweet Tomato Relish.

More from Charlie's Christmas Kitchen

Want all 24 recipes in one place, plus a Christmas Day timing plan and make ahead countdown? Get Charlie's free Christmas Kitchen kit.

Back to top